| SPORTS PARENTING
By Shelley
Smith
I watch in horror from the stands as one of the players on my daughter's high
school soccer team takes a swing at an opponent who has been taunting her since
the beginning of the game. As the rest of the girls run towards them, my
daughter rushes smack into the fight to break it up, grabbing her teammate from
behind while trying to push the other girl away, ending up on the bottom of the
pile kicking and clawing to get free.
I cringe as I hear a father, storming the sidelines of the field yell at his
daughter: "That was your fault. That's six mistakes in a row. Get your head
together or you're gonna hear about this at home." The young girl looks
over at him, terrified by his words even though it was clear she had heard them
before.
I listen with concern upon hearing about the number of female athletes now using
steroids or other performance-enhancing drugs, the number who have eating
disorders or who have been physically and verbally abused by their coaches or
sexually harassed. I shudder as I listen - to my own daughter and her teammates
- talk about the pressures and stress they feel to be the best, which makes them
physically ill before a game and has even led to nastiness between them because
of the competition on their own team.
"It's fun and I love to play," my daughter tells me. "But
sometimes it's really tough." The number of girls competing in sports has
never been higher. National studies estimate that one of every three high school
girls competes in some kind of sport. Close to half the nation's volleyball
players are girls and 40 percent of the nation's soccer players from ages 7 to
19 are female, compared to just 8 percent 10 years ago. But as the numbers of
female participants has increased, so has the number of problems. Fighting,
steroids, abusive coaches and problem parents have most generally been
associated only with boys' sports. Sadly, no more.
"There are so many things I see my daughter confronting being on a
volleyball team that I never experienced or even thought of when I was growing
up," one of my friends confided in me. "If we played anything it was
either because we were forced to do it in gym class or we knew the boys were
watching. Our biggest problem was keeping our uniform clean and our tennis shoes
white." This is a dilemma many women my age who have daughters in sports
are facing. Most of us missed out on the big sports boom. Title IX was nothing
more than another piece of ignored legislation when we were in middle and high
school. Plus, there was no one telling us about the benefits that come along
with participating in sports. There were no NIKE ads telling us that girls who
play sports are more likely to do better in school, have higher self-esteem, are
less likely to do drugs or join gangs, or even become sexually active. We didn't
even have NIKE yet. Competing or not competing was never an issue. Just do it?
We didn't.
So, like my friend, many of us don't have a clue. What do I tell my daughter
about fighting, or at least breaking up a fight? What role, if any, should I
take with regards to an abusive parent? How do I help my daughter focus on the
good things sports can bring into her life? What do I tell her when she plays
poorly or her team goes on a losing streak? How do I motivate her without
pushing? What is my role as a mom in this very strange new world?
It is often confusing. For example, the girls who were fighting were suspended
by their schools for two days. I know what I would have done at home beyond that
if it had been my daughter fighting - a lot of privileges would have been taken
away. But what do I tell her about her role in trying to break up the fight? I
know her intentions were good and that loyalty is important, but should she have
involved herself, risking possible serious injury or, perhaps, mistakenly be
named one of the instigators? I have never been in a fistfight and I had never
seen girls fight.
I called a friend who coaches men's college basketball. He told me that
teammates need to learn to stick up for one another and that sometimes means
joining in the fray, or at least pretending to join in.
"I always tell our guys that if a fight starts, go find a guy on the other
team who doesn't really want to fight either and act like you're restraining
each other," he said. "That way you're sticking up for your teammates,
but you're not putting yourself at risk." That seemed to make sense.
"But I had to do something to help Stephanie," my daughter insisted
when I passed on the advice. "And I was the closest to her." I sighed,
and just told her to be careful. What else could I say?
Should I have said something when I heard that father berating his daughter from
the sidelines? Or at least should I have told the girl's mother or counseled the
girl? I've seen enough of Bobby Knight to know that I don't approve of a coach
using verbal abuse as a motivating tactic so I know that I don't approve of it
coming from a father. But would confronting him make the situation better or
worse for his daughter?
As it turned out, I didn't have to say anything to the abusive father, who
repeated his tirade the next game. The coach told him to stop yelling negative
remarks and the father reacted badly, threatening to pull his daughter off the
team. Another father told me that as a child, he had been coached that same way
and just figured that was how he should coach his daughter - until his daughter
stopped talking to him. It took years for the damage to be repaired.
"Some athletes need to be yelled at," he said, "but I've never
seen a girl respond positively when she's berated by a parent or a coach. But
some parents don't get it. Some will never get it. And so you have to deal with
the girl - somehow get her to understand that he means well and is trying to
help, he just doesn't know how."
Fathers, it seems, need to learn a few things about their daughters, too. With
my own daughter, I worry constantly that she doesn't eat enough based on the
amount of training she does every day, competing in soccer and running track.
According to a national study, between 1 and 3 percent of all female athletes
are anorexic or bulemic, and that the percentage is even higher in adolescent
females. I pack her a healthy lunch (something that won't get stuck in her
braces) every day, but too often it comes home barely touched. She tells me that
sometimes there's no time for her to eat and sometimes she's just too tired.
There have been times in the morning where she's finishing up homework and I am
literally feeding her bites of her breakfast. And what about burnout? One
afternoon she came home completely spent from a two-hour track practice and had
just 90 minutes until soccer practice. She had guest-played for another team in
a tournament the previous weekend and was about as down and tired as I had ever
seen her. When I suggested she skip soccer that night, she exhaled with relief.
"I had nothing to look forward to today," she said. "I was so
tired but I knew I had track and Mondays are the hardest. We also get a ton of
homework on Mondays and then I knew I had just an hour or so until soccer. There
was nothing that I could feel excited about." We talked about the need to
push and strive and challenge herself, but also the importance of taking a break
now and then to recharge the batteries. This was something I've had to learn
myself in my career - like my daughter I tend to want to do everything and more
and do it better than anyone else. I used to drag myself in from a long trip and
jump into something else immediately. Now, I spend a day or two doing nothing,
and then get back up and do it again. At least I was speaking from experience
and she now is trying to cut herself some slack and relax for at least a couple
of hours every day. And when soccer season ends (does it ever end here in
California?) she says she's going to work out on her own, but take more time to
be a teenager and have some fun. That's important especially for girls, many of
whom quit their sport before ever finding out their true potential. One of my
daughter's high school teammates, for example, got a soccer scholarship to play
at Michigan State, but turned it down to be a "normal" college student
at UNLV. The challenge is to keep girls interested without making their sport
their entire life. A high school track coach I talked to reinforced the idea,
saying that he even approaches coaching girls differently than boys because of
their need to socialize.
"With my girls team I give them the first 15 minutes of practice just to
talke, catch up on the day's gossip, doings, whatever they want," he says.
"Then we start our drills. I don't need to do that with the boys. We start
from minute one. If I give them 15 minutes to socialize, they'll never get their
intensity back."
Both boys and girls need to understand the importance of valuing the process
rather than the result, several sports psychologists told me. Young athletes
have to learn to buy into the theory the act of competing is as important as the
competition itself, that performing well is just as good as winning. This, I've
found, is almost impossible. Everybody wants to win and winning is always the
goal. But it's very clear that most athletes will lose more often than they win.
So does that mean that playing is a waste? Of course not. But try telling that
to a young girl who just missed the winning shot or feels as if she didn't do
enough for her team.
"I just feel so bad," my daughter said after her team lost in the
semifinals of the city playoffs. "I couldn't find any intensity. I couldn't
do anything to help." Understand that she feels lousy, the experts say,
letting her know that it's okay to feel bad and that the reason she feels bad is
that she cares.
"The reason you feel horrible is the same reason that makes you so
good," I say. Did that make her feel any better? "Not really,"
she said. "We still lost." So much for the experts.
During the season, she witnessed a lot of sniping and finger pointing - some
directed her way for various reasons - she was the youngest on the team and yet
she was trying to direct players on the field as she has always done. The
comments got back to her and they stung.
"You can't worry about what you cannot control," I told her. "You
can't control what they think or what they say, but you can control what you
think and what you say. If you think you're right in what you're doing on the
field and your coach thinks you're right, then you don't have anything to worry
about." It still stung. Acceptance by peers is still a crucial part of
adolescence - sports or no sports - but acceptance by teammates has taken on
even more importance. Being part of a team doesn't necessarily mean she's part
of the team.
So it was somewhat ironic when, at school the day after the big fight on the
field, my daughter found that she had become a celebrity because of her
willingness to come to the aid of her teammate without regard for her own
situation.
"Major props for jumping in like that," a senior teammate said to her.
"And you're just a freshman, I've got to give it to you." Who would
have thought that something that horrified me ended up being something really
positive for my daughter because of her thought process and actions. It's very
different, I think, than what I would have done. But I wouldn't have been
playing. |